THE PAPER CHASE |

An info-overloaded law professor's syllabus of new law, learning and links... |  |


March 15, 2003 |

Saturday briefs
Ahead of an emergency US-UK-Spain summit in the Azores, UK Foreign Secretary Jack Straw said Saturday in a BBC Radio interview that a second UN Security Council resolution was not legally necessary for military action against Iraq. On the same BBC program, former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson doubted the legality of an Iraq war.... People for the American Way sponsored a debate on judicial nominations Friday. Watch The Right & The Law: How Far Right Conservatives Are Packing the Federal Courts on C-SPAN.... Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Senator Orrin Hatch spoke on privacy, technology and terrorism Friday at the Privacy and American Business Annual Conference in Washington, DC. Read a transcript of his speech.... The Egyptian Court of Cassation, that country's highest criminal tribunal, is expected to render a verdict Tuesday March 18 in the high-profile re-trial of democracy and human rights activist Eddin Ibrahim, a professor at the American University in Cairo who had previously been convicted by the State Security Court of illegally accepted foreign money and intentionally and maliciously working to damage Egypt's image. Neil Hicks of the Lawyers Committee for Human Rights offers background and perspective , and LCHR provides additional information on the case. Visit Eddin Ibrahim's own website for updates....
3/15/2003 11:02:59 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 15 - This day at law
US Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg was born on March 15, 1933. Learn more about Justice Ginsburg from the Oyez project at Northwestern University.
3/15/2003 09:13:12 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 14, 2003 |

New Jersey first state to make racial profiling a crime
New Jersey Governor James McGreevy Friday made his state the first to criminalize race-based arrests and police searches by signing a bill making those punishable by up to five years' imprisonment and a $15,000 fine. Read the Governor's press release and review the latest amended version of S429.
3/14/2003 05:24:39 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Human rights abuses in Zimbabwe - State Department report
On Thursday the US State Department released a special report on human rights in Zimbabwe documenting the abuses that led President Bush to issue an executive order March 7 - previously reported on JURIST - freezing the US assets of Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe and other government officials who he said were responsible for a "breakdown in the rule of law." Read Zimbabwe's Manmade Crisis and read a State Department news story on the background briefing that accompanied its release.
3/14/2003 05:09:56 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



The case for black reparations
Columbia University has posted a series of videos on the theme Forty Acres and a Mule: The Case for Black Reparations . Among the featured speakers is Charles Ogletree of Harvard Law School, currently leading a reparations lawsuit for descendants of victims of the 1921 Tulsa Race Riots.
3/14/2003 04:57:13 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



UN Security Council - Resolutions on Iraq
The US State Department Friday issued a new fact sheet on the UN Security Council ("how it works and serves US interests") detailing 17 Council Resolutions - including Resolution 1441 - that it says have been breached by Iraqi President Saddam Hussein since 1991.
3/14/2003 02:45:25 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Terror concerns prompt state lawmakers to lock public records
A University of Florida study presented Friday at the 2003 National Freedom of Information Day Conference in Arlington, Virginia shows that since the terrorist attacks on Sept. 11, 2001 state lawmakers have enacted dozens of legal and administrative rule-changes limiting public access to government-held information about building plans, evacuation procedures, medical supplies and other security-related issues. UF researchers at the Marion Brechner Citizen Access Project rated state laws on access to security, public safety and terrorism-related records on a scale from "sunny" - in reference to public access "sunshine laws" - to "dark," for the most closed. Louisiana, Ohio, Tennessee and the District of Columbia were rated "nearly dark" due to laws limiting access to many records on preparedness and security risks. Project Director Bill Chamberlin said: "It is one thing to keep sensitive information out of the hands of the terrorists, but quite another to use terrorism as an excuse to shield government officials from being accountable for their actions." Read the University of Florida press release and review state rankings on public access to records on preparation for and reaction to terrorism.
3/14/2003 01:48:23 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Rights oversight approved for US airline passenger screening system
The Senate Commerce Committee Thursday approved an amendment to the proposed Air Cargo Security Bill (S. 165) that would require the Homeland Security Secretary to report to Congress on the privacy and civil liberties impact of the Computer Assisted Passenger Prescreening System (CAPPS II) currently being developed by the Transportation Security Administration. Read a press release from amendment sponsor Senator Ron Wyden, and learn more about CAPPS II from Privacy Activism and the TSA.
3/14/2003 01:18:21 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Security Council delegates say no agreement on Iraq, but summit welcome
Ambassadors from UN Security Council members Germany and Pakistan spoke briefly at a press stakeout at UN Headquarters in New York Friday morning. While indicating there was as yet no agreement within the Council on an Iraq resolution, both delegates welcomed the newly-scheduled weekend summit in the Azores of leaders from draft sponsors UK, Spain and the United States. The ambassador from Pakistan also indicated that six of the non-permanent Security Council members were continuing negotiations amongst themselves on a possible new draft. Watch video from the UN.
3/14/2003 11:57:01 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Estrada cloture - third time lucky ?
The US Senate website indicates that yet another (the third...) cloture moton has been filed to terminate debate on the nomination of Miguel Estrada to the US DC Circuit Court of Appeals, and that the vote on the motion will occur Tuesday morning.
3/14/2003 10:51:50 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Law school briefs
Aviam Soifer, professor and former dean at Boston College Law School, is expected to be named dean of the University of Hawai'i William S. Richardson School of Law, says Friday's Honolulu Advertiser.... UC Berkeley School of Law (Boalt Hall) has announced that Professor Emeritus Sheldon Messinger, a distinguished scholar in the fields of criminology and sociology, died in Berkeley on March 6. More details are available from UC Berkeley.
3/14/2003 09:26:05 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



EU Parliament rejects sharing airline passenger data with US
By a vote of 414-44 Thursday the European Parliament passed a resolution "regretting" a February joint declaration[PDF] by US and EU officials which allows European airlines to provide US Customs personnel with data on passengers flying to the United States. The Parliament wants the European Commission to rescind the agreement - which it considers contrary to the European Data Protection Directive - and is considering a legal challenge in the European Court of Justice. Read the Parliament press release and review a provisional text of the resolution. Learn more about EU-US airline passenger data disclosure from the Electronic Privacy Information Center and review the FAQ from the EU External Relations office.
3/14/2003 09:01:02 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Senate Judiciary Committee - Owen nomination hearing video
The Senate Judiciary Committee has posted recorded video of yesterday's marathon hearing (over 9 hours) on the nomination of Priscilla Owen to the US Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. The opening statement of Ranking Democrat Senator Patrick Leahy is also available online.
3/14/2003 08:41:31 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 14 - This day at law
On March 14, 1964, nightclub owner Jack Ruby was convicted of the murder of Lee Harvey Oswald, who had presumably assassinated President John F. Kennedy on November 22, 1963. Ruby was sentenced to death. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals overturned Ruby's conviction in October 1966 and ordered a new trial citing improperly admitted testimony and an improper venue in the original proceeding, but Ruby died before the second trial could be convened. Review a transcript of Jack Ruby's July 1964 testimony before the Warren Commission investigated the assassination of President Kennedy. The Assistant Counsel for the Commission doing some of the questioning reported on the transcript is Arlen Spector, now a US Senator for Pennsylvania.
3/14/2003 07:51:44 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 13, 2003 |

Senate confirms Bybee nomination to Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
The Senate Thursday afternoon confirmed the nomination of Jay S. Bybee to the US Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals by a vote of 75-18. Read the official press release from the Ninth Circuit. Bybee was formerly a law professor on the faculty of the William S. Boyd School of Law, University of Nevada Las Vegas, where he taught civil procedure, constitutional law and administrative law.
3/13/2003 09:22:57 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Second Estrada cloture vote fails
The second cloture motion in the Senate to terminate debate over judicial nominee Miguel Estrada failed Thursday afternoon by a vote of 55-42 (60 votes required to carry; the first cloture motion on March 6 failed 55-44). President Bush issued a statement condemning "partisan obstructionist tactics," but the filibuster continues. The floor statement of Senate Judiciary Committee Ranking Democrat Patrick Leahy on the cloture motion is now available.
3/13/2003 04:16:08 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Law prof blog-watch
Here's what's happening on law professors' weblogs Thursday: Rick Hasen of Loyola Law School Los Angeles has a last word on his debate with colleague Lawrence Solum on political ideology and judicial selection.... Lawrence Solum, meanwhile, runs down a list of Thursday law faculty workshops.... Stanford Law's Larry Lessig parries criticism from GW Law's Orin Kerr on his characterization of judicial conduct in Eldred.... Eugene Volokh of UCLA offers a quick take on today's US 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruling on flag displays on overpasses, and gives advice on choosing good titles for legal articles.
3/13/2003 03:32:41 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Ninth Circuit flag display ruling
The US Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Thursday that the California Department of Transportation's policy of permitting an individual to display United States flags, but no other expressive banners, on highway overpasses was unreasonable viewpoint discrimination in violation of the First Amendment. Read Brown v. California Department of Transportation[PDF].
3/13/2003 03:17:22 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



ICTY President Judge - Djindjic assassination "heavy blow" to rule of law
The new President of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, NYU law professor Theodor Meron, issued a statement Thursday on yesterday's assassination of Serbian Prime Minister Zoran Djindjic, who had played a decisive role in bringing former Yugoslav President Slobodan Milsoevic to the ICTY for trial. Judge Meron said: "Mr. Djindjic’s cooperation with the Tribunal brought international justice closer to a region which saw terrible atrocities. His death is a heavy blow to individual accountability for violations of International Humanitarian Law and to the rule of law." Read the full statement from the ICTY.
3/13/2003 03:04:45 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



JURIST columnist re-opens Khmer Rouge genocide court talks in Cambodia
UN Legal Counsel and Under-Secretary-General for Legal Affairs Hans Corell met Thursday with Cambodian representatives to discuss how to proceed with negotiations on a draft agreement with the Cambodian government on the establishment of a special court to try cases arising from the Khmer Rouge "killing fileds" genocide of the 1970s. More details are available from the UN. Read Under-Secretary-General Corell's recent JURIST Forum op-ed Justice for the Killing Fields Re-negotiating the Khmer Rouge Genocide Court for Cambodia.
3/13/2003 02:52:46 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Amnesty calls for change, action from UN Human Rights Commission
In a press briefing Thursday, Amnesty International called for the UN Commission on Human Rights to revise its working methods and take concrete action in a variety of critical areas at its 59th session beginning next week. Read the AI briefing paper.
3/13/2003 02:41:10 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



First Circuit rejects war powers appeal
The US First Circuit Court of Appeals Thursday upheld a lower court ruling - previously reported in JURIST's Paper Chase - that had dismissed a complaint seeking a preliminary injunction to prevent President Bush and Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld from initiating a war against Iraq without proper Congressional authority. In the appeals court, Judge Sandra Lynch wrote:Many important questions remain unanswered about whether there will be a war, and, if so, under what conditions. Diplomatic negotiations, in particular, fluctuate daily. The President has emphasized repeatedly that hostilities still may be averted if Iraq takes certain actions. The Security Council is now debating the possibility of passing a new resolution that sets a final deadline for Iraqi compliance. United Nations weapons inspectors continue their investigations inside Iraq. Other countries ranging from Canada to Cameroon have reportedly pursued their own proposals to broker a compromise. As events unfold, it may become clear that diplomacy has either succeeded or failed decisively. The Security Council, now divided on the issue, may reach a consensus. To evaluate this claim now, the court would need to pile one hypothesis on top of another. We would need to assume that the Security Council will not authorize war, and that the President will proceed nonetheless.... If courts may ever decide whether military action contravenes congressional authority, they surely cannot do so unless and until the available facts make it possible to define the issues with clarity. Judge Lynch continued:Nor is there clear evidence of congressional abandonment of the authority to declare war to the President. To the contrary, Congress has been deeply involved in significant debate, activity, and authorization connected to our relations with Iraq for over a decade, under three different presidents of both major political parties, and during periods when each party has controlled Congress. It has enacted several relevant pieces of legislation expressing support for an aggressive posture toward Iraq, including authorization of the prior war against Iraq and of military assistance for groups that would overthrow Saddam Hussein. It has also accepted continued American participation in military activities in and around Iraq, including flight patrols and missile strikes. Finally, the text of the October Resolution itself spells out justifications for a war and frames itself as an "authorization" of such a war. It is true that "courts possess power to review either legislative or executive action that transgresses identifiable textual limits" on constitutional power.... But courts are rightly hesitant to second-guess the form or means by which the coequal political branches choose to exercise their textually committed constitutional powers. As the circumstances presented here do not warrant judicial intervention, the appropriate recourse for those who oppose war with Iraq lies with the political branches. Read the complete judgment in Doe v. Bush.
3/13/2003 02:25:10 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Fortress America?
The US State Department and the Department of Homeland Security have launched a new website providing official information on visa policy and procedures. Visit UnitedStatesVisas.gov. The quote from President Bush currently featured on the website front page is jarring and somewhat telling, although perhaps not intentionally so: "America is not a fortress; no, we never want to be a fortress. We're a free country; we're an open society."
3/13/2003 02:05:29 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



House Judiciary Committee hearing on copyright piracy, crime and terrorism
The House Judiciary Committee Subcommittee on Courts, the Internet, and Intellectual Property held a hearing Wednesday on "International Copyright Piracy: Links to Organized Crime and Terrorism." Witness statements are now available on the Subcommittee website.
3/13/2003 02:00:18 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



New on JURIST - call for papers
The Journal of the Association of Legal Writing Directors (JALWD) invites submission of proposals and articles for its Fall 2004 Learning/Thinking/Writing issue. In this "best practices" issue, the Journal will publish articles relating learning theory and cognitive research to the teaching and practice of professional legal writing. More details in JURIST's Calls for Papers.
3/13/2003 01:49:27 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



UN Secretary-General updates on Iraq
UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan updated reporters Friday morning on the state of negotiations on Iraq at a stakeout session at UN Headquarters in New York. He said a summit of heads of state - not necessarily Security Council members - might be called to work out a peaceful solution to the crisis. Watch recorded video from the UN.
3/13/2003 11:46:30 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Senate passes partial-birth abortion ban
By a vote of 64-33 the Senate Thursday passed legislation banning "partial-birth" late-term abortions. Read a floor statement by Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Senator Orrin Hatch from March 11 supporting the bill. The legislation now goes to the House, where it is expected to pass later this spring. NARAL Pro-Choice America (formerly the National Abortion Rights Action League) quickly slammed the bill in a press release, saying that it criminalized safe, legal abortion procedures and marked the beginning of a rollback of Roe v. Wade.
3/13/2003 11:22:53 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



France rejects UK changes to draft Security Council resolution on Iraq
Speaking Thursday in Paris, French Foreign Minister Dominique de Villepin rejected proposed UK amendments to the draft US-UK-Spain Security Council resolution authorizing use of military force against Iraq. De Villepin said that the amendments "do not address the issues raised by the international community." Read his full statement, now online from the French Embassy in Washington, DC.
3/13/2003 10:03:01 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Law school briefs
Most faculty at Harvard Law School appear to have no idea about who's being targeted in the HLS dean search, or when a candidate will be chosen, according to a story in Thursday's Harvard Crimson.... Also at HLS, Thursday's Harvard Law Record reports that former National Security Advisor Sandy Berger spoke to law students yesterday about a range of foreign policy issues, including the Iraq crisis.... School vouchers were the focus of a recent debate at Duke Law School.
3/13/2003 09:22:15 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Report from Belgrade - Serbia after Djindjic
A reader in Belgrade writes:I was invited by Mr. Djindjic a few days ago (last Friday) to explain my resignation from the new University Law Drafting Commission that had been formed by the Ministry of Education. I have to be sincere: I was not one of those who loved him with all my heart, as I was very unsatisfied with his executive's domination over legislative and judiciary branches here, which has precipitated an institutional crisis. I am afraid that the assassination is also a consequence of this. Nevertheless, I was impressed with his willingness to know what had happened and his initiative to talk with a single university professor about the issue when he had so many more important problems hanging over his head. His intelligence, openness and pragmatism were impressive....Having been with him so recently, I feel even more moved and aware of the loss we have suffered.So life goes on in Serbia, but the problem is in what direction? We willsee in a few days. If the police find the organizers of the assassination it will be a sign that this country, regardless of this tragedy, still has a chance to join the democratic world. New elections were in any case near, and only due to party political struggle and different maneuvers they did not take place yet. The elections for President of Serbia have also failed twice. I truly hope that Serbia still has strong democratic resources and candidates for elections - such as Mr. Labus and Mr. Kostunica - although the latter has been labeled as a nationalist. But Mr. Djindjic's recent call to review the Kosovo situation, which at the least is unsatisfactory, also tarred him with the nationalist label. The country is going to face a tough problem if the real organizers of the assassination cannot be found. It will not be easy to lead the country in the future, no matter who is going to be in position to do that, as they will be a hostage to personal insecurity. JURIST's Paper Chase welcomes reader comments at JURIST@law.pitt.edu.
3/13/2003 08:35:39 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 13 - This day at law
On March 13, 1925, Tennessee passed a law banning the teaching of evolution in schools. The violation of this law by a local schoolteacher resulted in the famous "Monkey Trial". Learn more about The State v. John Scopes from Douglas Linder of the University of Missouri-Kansas City School of Law in JURIST's Famous Trials series.
3/13/2003 06:11:42 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 12, 2003 |

Detainees ruling "dangerous precedent" - UN Human Rights Rapporteur
A United Nations Commission on Human Rights Special Rapporteur said Wednesday that Tuesday's US DC Circuit Court of Appeals ruling denying relief on jurisdictional grounds to Afghan war detainees held outside the US at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, had "far reaching" implications and could be a "dangerous precedent." Dato' Param Cumaraswamy, the Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers, said the decision appears to imply that a government of a sovereign State could lease a piece of land from a neighboring State, set up a detention camp, fully operate and control it, arrest suspects of terrorism from other jurisdictions, send them to this camp, deny them their legal rights -- including principles of due process generally granted to its own citizens -- on grounds that the camp is physically outside its jurisdiction. By such conduct, the Government of the United States, in this case, will be seen as systematically evading application of domestic and international law so as to deny these suspects their legal rights. Detention without trial offends the first principle of the rule of law. Read the Special Rapporteur's full statement on the ruling.
3/12/2003 10:45:34 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Justice Thurgood Marshall
J. Clay Smith of Howard University School of Law spoke Wednesday at Harvard Law School on his forthcoming book Supreme Justice, chronicling the life of late US Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall. Recorded video is now online from the Harvard Law School Saturday School program.
3/12/2003 10:24:22 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Human rights, sovereignty and terrorism
Louis Henkin of Columbia Law School spoke Wednesday in the latest of Columbia Law's Spring 2003 lecture series Columbia Goes to War. Watch recorded video of Human Rights in the Age of Terrorism - and What About Sovereignty? .
3/12/2003 09:20:52 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



UN Security Council open session on Iraq
The UN Security Council met Wednesday afternoon to allow more countries not members of the Council to present their views on the Iraq situation. Recorded video of the individual country statements is now available from the UN, along with video of the response by Iraq .
UPDATE [10:50 PM ET]: The UN has now posted a printed summary of Wednesday's session.
3/12/2003 08:55:36 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Supreme Court Olympic Airways stay
Early on Wednesday the US Supreme Court, per Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, granted a temporary stay of a US Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals judgment[PDF] that would have required Greek Olympic Airways to pay $1.4 million to the heirs of an asthmatic man who had died after inhaling second hand smoke on a long international flight. CNN has more. The stay Order is not yet available online.
3/12/2003 08:51:07 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Supreme Court stays Texas execution
Reuters reports that the US Supreme Court has issued a stay of execution for Delma Banks, scheduled to be executed by lethal injection Wednesday. The stay represents a preliminary legal victory for ex-FBI Director William Sessions, several former federal appeals judges and a former US DA for Chicago who had jointly filed an amicus brief[PDF] with the Court - previously reported in JURIST's Paper Chase - asking it to review Banks' case because of "uncured constitutional errors in the process through which he [Banks] was convicted and sentenced" which were "typical of those that have undermined public confidence in the fairness of our capital punishment system." Tonight's stay will give the Court time to consider whether it will actually take the case.
3/12/2003 08:29:22 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Video games ban appeal - oral arguments
The US Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals heard oral arguments Wednesday in Interactive Digital v. St. Louis County, in which video software producers submit that a county ban on the sale of violent video games to minors should be overturned as an unconstitutional infringement of free speech. Recorded audio of the oral arguments is now available from the Eighth Circuit (ironically for a case on multimedia, the audio pick-up on this recording is generally poor, but some exchanges are easily made out).
3/12/2003 05:58:02 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Senate judicial nominations hearing
The Senate Judiciary Committee held a hearing on judicial nominations Wednesday. Opening statements from Chairman Senator Orrin Hatch and Ranking Member Senator Patrick Leahy are now available online.
3/12/2003 05:11:55 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Technology and the courts
Canadian Supreme Court Justice Ian Binnie delivered a lecture entitled Technology and the Courts: The Incomprehensible Chasing the Unteachable? at the University of Toronto Faculty of Law on February 26. Watch recorded video , now online from U of T's Center for Innovation Law and Policy.
3/12/2003 03:03:09 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Is sunbathing more dangerous than terrorism?
University of Chicago law professor Cass Sunstein thinks it probably is, for most people. Read his op-ed from Tuesday's Los Angeles Times, now available (without registration or pop-ups!) from the University of Chicago Law School.
3/12/2003 02:56:25 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Proposed UK amendments to Security Council draft resolution
At a press conference in London Wednesday, UK Foreign Secretary Jack Straw said that the UK was discussing further amendments to the second draft UN Security Council resolution[PDF] (co-sponsored by the US and Spain) it had introduced at the Security Council on March 7, and was circulating six tests for Iraqi compliance:- a statement by Saddam Hussein admitting that he has concealed weapons of mass destruction, but will no longer produce or retain weapons of mass destruction;
- deliver at least 30 scientists for interview outside Iraq, with their families;
- surrender all anthrax, or credible evidence of destruction;
- complete the destruction of all Al Samoud missiles;
- account for all unmanned aerial vehicles, including details of any testing of sparying devices for chemical and biological weapons;
- surrender all mobile chemcial and biological production facilities.
Read the full text of the Foreign Secretary's statement, now online from the UK Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
3/12/2003 02:43:21 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



US civil liberties, human rights downhill since Sept. 11 - LCHR report
The Lawyers Committee for Human Rights issued an updated report Tuesday on what it described as the steadily-eroding state of civil liberties and human rights in the United States over the 18 months that have passed since the attacks of September 11. LCHR President Michael Posner said in a press release that "In the last six months in particular, the executive branch has taken a series of measures to consolidate its authority and these actions have, in some cases, prevented Congress and the courts from playing their safeguarding roles. In other cases, Congress and the judiciary have been too submissive or deferential.” Read the full text of Imbalance of Powers[PDF], covering developments relevant to open government; the right to privacy; the treatment of immigrants, refugees and minorities; and security detainees and the criminal justice system.
3/12/2003 01:16:45 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Amnesty bemoans detainees ruling, welcomes Padilla access to counsel
In a statement Wednesday, Amnesty International said that Tuesday's federal appeal court ruling denying on jurisdictional grounds any legal relief to Afghan war detainees held by the US at Guanatanamo Bay, Cuba (and reported previously in JURIST's Paper Chase) "will cause further damage to the international reputation of the USA and to fundamental human rights standards agreed to across the world." Read the AI press release. In a related development, Amnesty welcomed Tuesday's US District Court ruling allowing accused "dirty bomber" Jose Padilla access to a lawyer (also reported here previously), but said it represented only "the smallest step forward for justice in this case and others in the war on terrorism."
3/12/2003 12:56:53 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Second cloture vote on Estrada coming Thursday
The US Senate website indicates that a cloture vote on the nomination of Miguel Estrada to the DC Circuit Court of Appeals has been scheduled for tomorrow (Thursday), March 13. The previous cloture motion made on March 6 was defeated 55-44.
3/12/2003 11:26:04 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



New scholarship - Nietzsche and judicial authority in America
Wednesday on SSRN:
Retaining Judicial Authority: A Preliminary Inquiry on the Dominion of American Judges by Larry Cara Backer of the Pennsylvania State University - Dickinson School of Law From the Abstract: "Why do the people and institutions of democratic states, and in particular those of the United States, obey judges? This article examines the foundations of judicial authority in the United States. This authority is grounded on principles of dominance derived from the organization of institutional religion. The judge in Western states asserts authority on the same basis as the priest - but not the priest as conventionally understood. Rather, the authority of the judge in modern Western democratic states is better understood when viewed through the analytical lens of priestly function developed in the philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche. Focusing on the American Supreme Court, this paper examines the manner in which high court judges have successfully internalized the characteristics of Nietzsche - Paul and his priestly caste within the religion of Western constitutionalism."
3/12/2003 10:29:56 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Law school briefs
Harvard Law School students attending a forum Tuesday with Harvard University President Lawrence Summers accused him of ignoring them in the Law School's current Dean Search. More from the Harvard Crimson. AP also reports. HLS Federalist Society blogger Adam White was there....
The National Rifle Association (NRA) has announced that its NRA Foundation has pledged $1 million to the George Mason University School of Law to establish and endow the Patrick Henry Professorship of Constitutional Law and the Second Amendment. The Washington Times has more....
Steven Bahls, dean of Ohio's Capital University School of Law, is stepping down to become president of Augustana College in Rock Island, Ill. Read the law school press release....
The University of Mexico School of Law hosted a panel discussion Tuesday on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The UNM Daily Lobo reports....
3/12/2003 09:19:41 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Ocalan trial unfair - ECHR
The European Court of Human Rights ruled Wednesday that Turkey had violated the rights of captured Kurdish rebel leader Abdullah Ocalan by delaying his trial and had not tried him before an independent and impartial tribunal. Read the ECHR press release summarizing the judgment.
3/12/2003 08:59:15 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Breaking news - Serbian Prime Minister assassinated
Serbian Prime Minister Zoran Djindjic, a democratic reformer who played a decisive role in sending former Yugoslav President Slobodan Milosevic to The Hague for trial on war crimes, was assassinated Wednesday in front of government offices in Belgrade. More from the BBC. The news is not yet official - the Serbian Government website is still only saying that Djindic was "injured."
UPDATE [11:10 AM ET]: The Serbian Government website is now acknowledging the assassination, saying: "This criminal act is a clear attempt to put an end to the development and democratisation of Serbia and plunge it into isolation once again and was carried out by those who have been trying over the past few years to do so through various murders and assassinations." Radio B-92 in Belgrade is posting English-langauge updates on the situation and reactions as they come in.
3/12/2003 08:51:15 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 12 - This day at law
On March 12, 1993, Janet Reno was sworn in an as the first female US Attorney General. Learn more about Janet Reno from the US Department of Justice Attorney General's website as it stood on November 9, 2000.
3/12/2003 08:37:42 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 11, 2003 |

Canadian to preside over International Criminal Court
Philippe Kirsch of Canada was chosen as President of International Criminal Court by the Court's newly-sworn judges at its inauguration at The Hague Tuesday. Judge Kirsch is a former Canadian diplomat and Chairman of the Preparatory Commission for the Establishment of the International Criminal Court. In July 1998 he chaired the Committee of the Whole of the Rome Conference, which adopted the statute of the Court. Read a brief McGill Law Journal article by Judge Kirsch on the prospects for the ICC written in 2000. The Court's new Vice Presidents hail from Ghana (Akua Kuenyehia) and Costa Rica (Elizabeth Odio Benito). UN Radio has more on the Court's inauguration ceremony and the election of Judge Kirsch.
3/11/2003 09:37:35 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



More concerns expressed over alleged US mistreatment of detainees
The Lawyers Committee for Human Rights sent a letter to US Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld Tuesday expressing "grave concerns" over allegations of US mistreatment of security detainees: We urge you to address these issues personally and publicly by making clear the unambiguous US prohibition against all forms of torture and other cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment or punishment. As you know, these practices are strictly prohibited under international laws, to which the United States is a party, including the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman and Degrading Treatment or Punishment (the Torture Convention) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. The use of torture also violates a 1994 U.S. federal law that explicitly provides penalties of fines and up to 20 years imprisonment for acts of torture committed by U.S. officials outside of the U.S. (18 U.S.C. § 2340 A). As you also know, many practices that do not constitute "torture" are still strictly prohibited as "other acts of cruel and inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment" under article 16 of the Torture Convention. When the Senate ratified this treaty it construed this language as applying standards that are consistent with U.S. domestic legal principles. Read the full text of the letter[PDF], which follows the deaths of several prisoners while in US custody, several reported suicide attempts by detainees, and similar expressions of concern by the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights and the New York-based monitoring group Human Rights Watch previously mentioned in JURIST's Paper Chase.
3/11/2003 09:13:24 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Countries address Security Council on Iraq
Twenty-six countries and international organizations[PDF] addressed the UN Security Council Tuesday at an open session on Iraq. Watch recorded video or review a printed summary of remarks from the UN. More countries[PDF] are scheduled to speak when the open session resumes Wednesday afternoon at 3 PM ET.
3/11/2003 08:42:36 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Minority rights in Kosovo - UN/OSCE report
A joint report on minority rights in Kosovo issued Tuesday by the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) says that despite progress, problems of discrimination in the UN-administered territory remain. The report concludes: Further fundamental changes need to be made in order to improve conditions for Kosovo's minorities and to create an environment conducive for returns of all ethnic groups. While improvements have been seen in many areas since the last Assessment, concerns remain in minorities' access to justice, essential services, property rights, and public, civil, and political structures and their security and freedom of movement in Kosovo. Review the Tenth Assessment of the Situation of Ethnic Minorities in Kosovo[PDF].
3/11/2003 04:46:53 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Now in English - Chirac interview promising French veto on Iraq
The French Embassy in Washington has posted an English translation of French President Jacque Chirac's interview Monday evening on French TV - the French-language broadcast version of which was featured yesterday in JURIST's Paper Chase - in which he said that France would veto a US-UK resolution authorizing force against Iraq.
3/11/2003 04:00:19 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



"Dirty bomber" access to counsel ruling
US District Judge Michael Mukasey's Tuesday ruling[PDF] reaffirming his December holding[PDF] that "dirty bomber" Jose Padilla - currently detained by the United States as an "enemy combatant" - be allowed to consult with counsel is now available online from the US Southern District of New York. Apparently frustrated by the Government's disputation of his original decision, Mukasey concluded: "Lest any confusion remain, this is not a suggestion or a request that Padilla be permitted to consult with counsel, and it is certainly not an invitation to conduct a further “dialogue” about whether he will be permitted to do so. It is a ruling -- a determination -- that he will be permitted to do so." The US Department of Justice issued a statement on the ruling saying that it would "review today's opinion in light of our duty to take all steps possible within the law to protect the American people."
3/11/2003 03:36:41 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Iraq, the UN, and the threat of war
Ohio State University's Moritz College of Law hosted a panel discussion March 7 on Iraq, the UN, and the threat of war. Streaming video is now available.
3/11/2003 02:57:12 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Law prof blog-watch
Stanford Law School's Larry Lessig breaks a long silence on his blog now that Eldred v. Ashcroft is finally over, the Supreme Court Monday having refused a petition to rehear [the subject, by the way, of a somewhat critical assessment by DC appellate lawyers Goldstein & Howe on their SCOTUSblog].
Yale Law's Jack Balkin takes the US Justice Department to task for insisting that as an enemy combatant, "dirty bomber" Jose Padilla has no constitutional rights, an argument that was rejected Tuesday by US District Judge Michael Mukasey in reaffirming his December ruling holding that Padilla be allowed to consult with counsel.
Peter Tillers of Cardozo Law School is back on his JURIST Evidence blog with a conference plug and some suggested readings.
UCLA's Eugene Volokh is torn over the legality of torture.
Lawrence Solum of Loyola Law School Los Angeles wraps up his debate with colleague Rick Hasen on political ideology and judicial selection.
Loyola's Rick Hasen, meanwhile, has been reading President Bush's letter on judicial nominations and has a suggestion.
3/11/2003 02:15:24 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



EU court rejects law student's claim that military service is discriminatory
The European Court of Justice Tuesday rejected a German law student's claim that Germany's compulsory military conscription of young men, and not women, breached EU job equality law. Alexander Dory had argued that military service had a discriminatory impact because mens' careers were delayed, while those of exempt women were not. The Court ruled, however, that European states could choose how to organise their own militaries, and were not subject to EU law in that respect. Read the ECJ press release summarizing the judgment.
3/11/2003 01:55:34 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Bush letter to Senate on judicial nominations
Frustrated with the continuing debate on Miguel Estrada and declaring that the "judicial confirmation process is broken," President Bush sent a letter Tuesday to Senate leaders Bill Frist and Tom Daschle asking Senators of both parties to come together and "take action, including adoption of a permanent rule, to ensure timely up or down votes on judicial nominations both now and in the future, no matter who is President or which party controls the Senate." Read the full text of the letter.
3/11/2003 12:41:09 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



SEC on partial settlement of ImClone insider-trading case
The Securities and Exchange Commission announced Tuesday that it has agreed to a partial settlement of its insider trading civil suit against former ImClone Systems Inc. chief executive Samuel Waksal under which Waksal would be barred from acting as an officer of any publicly traded company and would pay back more than $800,000 in insider trading profits. Read the SEC press release and review the SEC's amended complaint against Waksal, who still neither admits or denies the allegations against him.
3/11/2003 12:18:40 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Appeals court denies relief to Afghan war detainees
A panel of the US DC Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Tuesday that it had no jurisdiction to hear claims of unlawful detention brought by 16 Afghan war detainees - including two Britons and two Australians - held without access to lawyers or their families at the US Navy base at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba. Upholding a lower court ruling, the Court said its jurisdiction did not extend to non-resident aliens outside the sovereign territory of the United States (sovereignty over the Guantanamo Bay base properly belonging to the nation of Cuba, which leased it to the US indefinitely in 1903). Read Al Odah et al. v. US[PDF]. The ruling drew a statement from Attorney General John Ashcroft.
3/11/2003 11:53:58 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



International Criminal Court - continuing coverage
UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan's statement to the inaugural meeting of the judges of the International Criminal Court at The Hague Tuesday in now online from the UN. UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Sergio Vieira de Mello also issued a statement.
3/11/2003 11:34:00 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Justice for the "killing fields"
New online Tuesday in JURIST's Forum op-ed series: UN Under-Secretary-General for Legal Affairs Hans Corell, who's heading to Phnom Penh this week, says that any Cambodian crimes court has to be set up in such a way as to guarantee its impartiality, independence and credibility. Read Justice for the Killing Fields: Re-negotiating a Khmer Rouge Genocide Court for Cambodia right here on JURIST.
3/11/2003 11:21:50 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



International Criminal Court
The International Criminal Court is officially inaugurated today at The Hague. The Court has a brand new website, which will carry streaming video of the inauguration ceremony - including the swearing-in of the judges by UN Secretary General Kofi Annan - live beginning at about 8:30 AM ET (14:30 CET).
3/11/2003 07:45:01 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 11 - This day at law
On March 11, 1861, seven former US states adopted the Constitution of the Confederate States of America, which closely followed the language, if not necessarily the purport, of the original US Constitution.
3/11/2003 07:26:23 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 10, 2003 |

France, Russia will veto US Iraq resolution - Security Council vote postponed
French President Jacques Chirac said Monday evening in an interview on French television that France will cast its Security Council veto against a second US-UK draft resolution authorizing the use of force against Iraq. Watch the full interview with President Chirac on France 2 [in French]. Earlier in the day, as reported in the English-language Moscow Times, Russian Foreign Minister Igor Ivanov had said that Russia would vote against the resolution as presently worded. Without explicitly referring to either of these developments, the State Department indicated late Monday that the United States would not ask the Security Council to vote on the resolution (originally scheduled for consideration Tuesday) until later in the week.
3/10/2003 08:37:15 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Executive Order freezing Zimbabwean assets
President Bush's Executive Order issued Friday - and previously reported on JURIST - freezing US assets of Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe and 76 associates in light of the threat to US foreign policy due to what the US considers the "breakdown of the rule of law" in that country is now available online from the White House.
3/10/2003 04:18:00 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



War against Iraq without Council OK would breach UN Charter - Annan
In a news conference in Geneva today UN Secretary General Kofi Annan said that "if the US and others were to go outside the Council and take military action [against Iraq] it would not be in conformity with the Charter." Read a full transcript of his remarks from the UN.
3/10/2003 03:23:03 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Hatch on judicial confirmations
Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Senator Orrin Hatch discussed the judicial confirmations process at The Heritage Foundation in Washington, DC Monday. Watch recorded video of his remarks on C-SPAN.
3/10/2003 02:17:17 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Brief by ex-FBI Director, judges and prosecutor against Texas execution
As reported in Monday's Washington Post, former FBI Director William Sessions, former US Court of Appeals Judges Timothy Lewis and John Gibbons (3rd Circuit) and former US Attorney for Chicago and co-chair of the Illinois Governor's Commission on Capital Punishment Thomas Sullivan have filed an amicus brief in the Supreme Court asking it to review the case of Delma Banks, scheduled to be executed in Texas Wednesday. The brief, which focuses on critical questions regarding prosecutorial suppression of evidence and ineffective assistance of counsel at Banks' trial, can be read here[PDF].
3/10/2003 01:03:27 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



World Court concludes hearings in Iran v. US oil platforms litigation
The International Court of Justice at The Hague concluded public hearings Friday in the case of Iran v. United States, arising out of the destruction of several offshore Iranian oil-drilling platforms by US destroyers in 1987 and 1988. The Court is now set to begin deliberations.
3/10/2003 12:38:43 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Monday's US Supreme Court cert. grants
Also from Goldstein & Howe in DC: "The Court granted cert. today in (i) No. 02-693, Lamie v. U.S. Trustee (which involves the availability of attorney's fees in bankruptcy) [disclosure: we represent the petitioner]; (ii) No. 02-628, Frew v. Hawkins (which involves a state's immunity from a consent decree); (iii) No. 02-682, Verizon v. Law Offices of Curtis V. Trinko (which is a telecommunications antitrust case); and (iv) No. 02-6320, Fellers v. United States (which may involve a Miranda question, we're checking)."
UPDATE [2:19 PM ET]: Further information on the grants is now available from G&H.
3/10/2003 11:19:16 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Monday's US Supreme Court rulings
From DC Supreme Court litigators Goldstein & Howe: The Court today affirmed in two cases. In No. 01-1572, Cook County v. U.S.[PDF], Justice Souter held for a unanimous Court that local govenrments, unlike States, are 'persons' subject to qui tam actions under the False Claims Act.... In No. 01-963, Norfolk & Western Railway v. Ayers[PDF], Justice Ginsburg held for a unanimous Court that damages awarded under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA) need not be apportioned according to causal contribution among even absent joint tortfeasors. For a five-Justice majority, Justice Ginsburg further held that mental anguish damages resulting from the fear of developing cancer may be recovered under FELA by a railroad worker suffering from the actionable injury asbestosis caused by work-related exposure to asbestos. On this question Justice Kennedy dissented, joined by the Chief Justice and Justices O'Connor and Breyer, and Justice Breyer also filed a separate partial dissent explaining why he did not join the majority opinion on the mental anguish damages holding. HTML versions of Cook County and Norfolk & Western Railway are available from Cornell's Legal Information Institute.
3/10/2003 11:05:26 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Law prof blog-watch
Yale Law's Jack Balkin has been reading Deborah Sontag's Sunday New York Times article on the US Fouth Circuit Court of Appeals, and reflects on the importance of so-called "inferior courts."
Lawrence Solum of Loyola Law School Los Angeles continues his online debate with colleague Rick Hasen on politics and judging.
Tung Yin at the University of Iowa College of Law reports in his weblog on a affirmative action debate Friday that featured James Lindgren of Northwestern University School of Law, and offers his thoughts on the Gratz case and the diversity rationale for affirmative action admissions.
3/10/2003 10:39:11 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



New scholarship - school vouchers, the Guarantee Clause
New and interesting papers on SSRN today include:
School Vouchers and the Constitution - Permissible, Impermissible, or Required? by Gary Simson of Cornell Law School From the Abstract: "This article focuses on two Supreme Court decisions with major implications for the constitutionality of school vouchers: Pierce v. Society of Sisters in 1925, which held on due process grounds that the state cannot compel parents to send their children to public school; and Zelman v. Simmons-Harris in 2002, which held that vouchers for parochial school education do not violate the Establishment Clause."
Leaving the Empty Vessel of "Republicanism" Unfilled: An Argument for the Continued Non-Justiciability of Guarantee Clause Cases by Richard Hasen of Loyola Law School Los Angeles From the Abstract: "Many commentators trace the beginning of the end of the political question doctrine to the Supreme Court's 1962 Baker v. Carr decision. In Baker, as Mark Tushnet has explained, the Court domesticated the doctrine by reducing it from an amorphous prudential doctrine to a set of six legal rules. If the political question doctrine continues to have any vitality, it is in the area of foreign and in cases raising "Guarantee Clause" claims. I ignore the foreign affairs area and focus on the Guarantee Clause. Cases raising Guarantee Clause claims now stand on the cusp of justiciability."
3/10/2003 10:18:57 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



International Criminal Court
UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan is in The Hague this week for Tuesday's inauguration of the new International Criminal Court. Details on inauguration events[PDF] at The Hague and elsewhere are available from the Coalition for the International Criminal Court.
3/10/2003 10:10:19 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



A recess appointment for Estrada?
Victor Williams of Catholic University School of Law says that a recess appointment for Miguel Estrada could be the way out of the current confirmation stand-off (which, by the way, resumes in the Senate at 2 PM this afternoon). Read his op-ed in Monday's National Law Journal.
UPDATE [4:20 PM ET]: Judicial nominations guru Howard Bashman suggests that Williams' idea should be taken with a very large grain of salt. See his 2001 article, Questioning the Constitutionality of Recess Appointments to the Federal Judiciary.
3/10/2003 09:51:00 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



CIPA oral argument notes
Notes from last Wednesday's Supreme Court oral arguments in the CIPA (Children's Internet Protection Act) library-filtering case have been posted online by Skip Auld, Assistant Director of the Chesterfield County (VA) Public Library, who was in the courtroom. An official transcript is not yet available. [LawMeme]
3/10/2003 09:44:33 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



INS screening of incoming travelers inadequate - DOJ report
In an internal report some details of which were released Monday, the US Department of Justice auditor found that the capability of INS screening staff at airports to analyze advance passenger information so as to identify high-risk and inadmissible travelers entering the United States was "limited due to the lack of adequate resources," and that existing procedures did not always provide INS inspectors critical information on such passengers. An executive summary of the DOJ report is available online.
3/10/2003 09:22:55 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



Law school breaking news - Delgado, Stefancic appointed at U. Pittsburgh
In an online exclusive, JURIST announced Monday that leading critical race theorist Richard Delgado and noted legal writer Jean Stefancic have been named to two new professorships at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law designated in honor of Derrick Bell, a pioneer of the critical race movement and a 1957 Pitt Law graduate. Delgado and Stefancic come to Pittsburgh from the University of Colorado School of Law at Boulder; their appointments will be effective in May.
Delgado - who's been called the most prolific and one of the most influential legal scholars in America - told JURIST Sunday: "I'm delighted at the prospect of joining the outstanding Pittsburgh law faculty, reaping the benefits of the new Center on Race and Social Problems, meeting the Pittsburgh community, and --after 14 years in Colorado--enjoying some good ethnic food!" Stefancic added, "My friends say, "You're leaving Colorado for Pittsburgh?" And I say, "Who wouldn't want to join an energetic vital law school, be part of a dynamic urban university, and live in a charming historical city?" I can't wait to get there!" Read the full press release exclusively online on JURIST.
3/10/2003 08:34:04 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 10 - This day at law
On March 10, 1969, James Earl Ray was sentenced to 99 years in prison for the murder of civil rights leader Martin Luther King, Jr.. Ray died in 1998, still seeking a retrial of his case. On December 9th, 1999, a Memphis jury handed down a verdict agreeing with the King family that the 1968 assassination of the civil rights leader was a conspiracy rather than the act of a lone gunman. Learn more about the trial and the assassination from The King Center in Atlanta.
3/10/2003 07:07:36 AM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



March 9, 2003 |

Sunday briefs
The US Department of Justice Bureau of Justice Statistics Sunday released a report showing that less than half of all violent crimes committed in the United States in 2000 were actually reported to police, because victims felt the crimes were personal and private matters, or injuries sustained were deemed insignificant. Read Reporting Crime to the Police, 1992-2000.
Also Sunday, former President Jimmy Carter condemned an American war against Iraq in a New York Times editorial suggesting that it was contrary to international law and could not legitimized as a "just war":Profound changes have been taking place in American foreign policy, reversing consistent bipartisan commitments that for more than two centuries have earned our nation greatness. These commitments have been predicated on basic religious principles, respect for international law, and alliances that resulted in wise decisions and mutual restraint. Our apparent determination to launch a war against Iraq, without international support, is a violation of these premises. The full text of Just War, or a Just War? is also available from the Carter Center. Speaking Saturday to law students at Drake Law School, Democratic Presidential candidate Senator John Kerry derided the Bush's Administration's push for conservative judges, saying that ''Our courts should never be the wholly owned subsidiaries of any one political party, any one point of view, any one ideology or any one president." Read more from AP.
3/9/2003 06:53:17 PM by Bernard Hibbitts | link | latest Paper Chase | back to JURIST



|

 The Paper Chase - Archives
Put a law professor on your website! Thanks to the magic of RSS, The Paper Chase is now available for websites as well as personal news aggregators. If you'd like to display up to 16 of The Paper Chase's latest posts on new law and learning in digest or headline-only form on your law school, law library, law firm or court website or intranet, or on your law-related weblog, e-mail JURIST@law.pitt.edu for permission and instructions. The service can be customized for size, color and font, is completely commercial-free, and is provided at no charge as an academic service to the community.
 Hello, I'm Bernard Hibbitts, JURIST's Editor, blogger for JURIST's Paper Chase, and a law professor at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Join The Paper Chase for some real-time legal education as together we follow noteworthy new law, the latest in legal learning, and timely links to key online resources. Tips? Suggestions? E-mail JURIST@law.pitt.edu.

|

|